Technology

Why Federal Regulators Are Questioning Waymo's Fix for Passing School Buses

Martin HollowayPublished 9h ago4 min readBased on 9 sources
Reading level
Why Federal Regulators Are Questioning Waymo's Fix for Passing School Buses
Photo by Anthony Quintano from Mount Laurel, United States / CC BY 2.0

Federal safety regulators say most of the reported cases of Waymo robotaxis illegally passing school buses happened after the company had already released a software fix for the problem.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) made that statement in a November 6, 2026 filing. A robotaxi is a self-driving car that carries passengers without a human driver. The agency's Office of Defects Investigation has now opened a recall query, which is a formal review of whether the fix is good enough. The NHTSA filing is the agency's most recent public statement on the matter.

Waymo is owned by Alphabet, the parent company of Google. The company said it finished a software update for all affected vehicles on November 17, 2025. NHTSA opened its first investigation in October 2025, after video surfaced of a Waymo vehicle driving around a stopped school bus in Atlanta.

In that video, the robotaxi crossed in front of the bus while its stop arm was out and its red lights were flashing. Children were getting off the bus at the time. The car then turned left around the front of the bus.

The problem was not limited to Georgia. In an earlier incident on September 22, 2025, a Waymo vehicle slowed to 5 mph for a school bus. It then drove on before the bus had pulled its stop arm back in.

Officials at Austin Independent School District reported at least five cases of Waymo vehicles illegally passing stopped school buses. In a November 20 letter, the district said five more incidents happened in November, after Waymo's updates were meant to fix the issue. Reuters reported earlier that Austin had seen no fewer than 19 illegal passes since the start of the school year. Federal regulators are also investigating several incidents in Texas.

A separate case involves a child. Waymo said its vehicle spotted a child near a school and braked hard. The National Transportation Safety Board, which investigates serious transportation accidents, is also looking into an incident in which a Waymo vehicle struck a child near a school. The school bus review and the child strike investigation are run by different federal bodies and ask different questions. They should not be combined into one finding.

The main point of the filing is timing. A software fix only counts if it works on real streets. NHTSA's statement that most violations came after the update suggests the fix did not hold up in everyday driving.

Waymo says the update reached every affected vehicle. Both claims could be true at once. The recall query is meant to find out which problem is behind the incidents. The software may not have covered every situation. The system may not have recognized stop arms and flashing lights well enough. Or some vehicles may not have received the update the way the company described.

In my view, the real question for companies running driverless fleets is not whether a software fix can be sent out. It is whether they can prove the fix works in the field, for a specific danger that the law defines clearly. A stopped school bus with its arm out is a clear, well-documented situation, which makes it a good test. If the review explains why this fix fell short, the methods used could help regulators and companies check fixes for other rare situations before cars are trusted near children.