Technology

SpaceX Tries to Catch Starship's Upper Stage for the First Time

Martin HollowayPublished 54m ago3 min readBased on 1 source
Reading level
SpaceX Tries to Catch Starship's Upper Stage for the First Time
Photo by Jay Wedgeworth on Unsplash

SpaceX planned its first attempt to catch the upper stage of its Starship rocket, called the Ship, during Flight 15. The flight launched from Texas. According to Engadget, the Ship stayed in orbit around Earth for roughly 22 hours. The catch attempt was expected shortly after 4 p.m. ET on Saturday, 14 November.

The flight was built around two catches. The first was for the Super Heavy booster, the large bottom stage. Giant mechanical arms on the launch tower, which SpaceX calls chopsticks, were meant to grab the booster as it came back down. The Ship was to try the same move a day later.

SpaceX had already caught Super Heavy boosters several times. Earlier V1 boosters had been caught and flown again a couple of times. So the booster catch was not new. The Ship catch is the new part.

The booster did not finish its job. The Flight 15 booster stopped its catch attempt and was sent to splash down in the Gulf. It exploded before it reached the water, according to Engadget. That removed the booster from the plan. The Ship's catch was still scheduled.

Flight 15 also released 26 Starlink V3 satellites into orbit. Starlink is SpaceX's internet network, and V3 is its newest generation of satellites. The test flight was therefore carrying satellites meant for the working network, not only running a demonstration.

The two catches are different jobs. A booster comes back on a short, curved path and is caught low in the atmosphere. The Ship spends its time in orbit, so it returns from much farther away and faces a different kind of re-entry. The catch tests steering, heat control during re-entry, and mechanical capture, all working together.

The 22 hours in orbit give the Ship time to line up for its approach. They also make the Ship's catch a later and tighter event, with less room for error at the final moment.

In my view, the booster abort is the detail most worth weighing before the Ship attempt. A catch that depends on one vehicle returning intact to a fixed point leaves little room for a late problem. The Flight 15 booster showed how quickly a planned catch can turn into a controlled splash in open water. Whether the Ship follows the same path is something the flight data will answer, not the plan.

The broader context here is that a successful Ship catch would move Starship from recovering its hardware to recovering the vehicle that carries payloads. For reuse, that is a different kind of operation. A tower able to catch both stages would need less ocean recovery and could allow faster turnaround between flights. Those are results of a successful attempt, not of the plan alone.

SpaceX planned the first Ship catch for Flight 15. The booster catch failed, and the booster was lost. The Ship was scheduled to attempt its capture on Saturday afternoon, after about 22 hours in orbit. The result will show whether the tower's arms can become the standard way to recover the full vehicle.