Technology

Google's New Chrome Rules Are Changing How Ad Blockers Work

Martin HollowayPublished 21h ago4 min readBased on 7 sources
Reading level
Google's New Chrome Rules Are Changing How Ad Blockers Work

Google is phasing out an older system for Chrome extensions called Manifest V2. This affects ad blockers, privacy tools, and content filters that millions of people use every day to customize how their browser works.

The change started in June 2024 in test versions of Chrome. Google announced the replacement system, called Manifest V3, back in 2018, saying it would make extensions more secure, protect privacy better, and run faster. Developers got three years to update their tools before the old system stopped working. That deadline is now here.

What's actually changing

The core issue comes down to how extensions filter what shows up on your screen. Under the old system, extensions could watch web traffic as it flows through your browser in real time and make on-the-fly decisions about what to block. Think of it like a customs officer who can examine each package individually and decide right then whether to let it through.

The new system works differently. Extensions have to declare their filtering rules in advance, and Google sets a limit on how many rules they can use. It's like writing down a checklist before the packages arrive — less flexible, but potentially faster and safer because the extension can't dynamically load complex instructions while you're browsing.

Ad blocker developers have disagreed about whether this works. AdGuard released a new version that runs under the new rules, though the company admits it has tradeoffs. Raymond Hill, who develops the popular uBlock Origin ad blocker, has been more critical. He built a simpler version for the new system but says it's noticeably weaker than the original.

How much does Chrome already block on its own

Chrome itself has built-in ad filtering. Since 2018, Chrome has automatically blocked ads on websites that use particularly annoying formats. By 2019, it was blocking all ads on sites that repeatedly violated those standards. Chrome also blocks ads that eat up too much of your device's power or data — like ads that use more than 4 MB of downloads or 15 seconds of processing time in any 30-second window.

But Chrome's own blocking is pretty basic. It targets only the most obnoxious ads. It doesn't handle the tracking scripts, invisible pixels, and fingerprinting tools that most people install ad blockers to stop.

The business context matters here

Google makes its money from advertising. It also controls Chrome, the world's most popular browser, and owns or operates much of the advertising network that extensions try to block. This creates an obvious tension.

Google says the new rules are about security — and there's real truth to that; powerful extensions do represent a security risk. But the timing and specific choices have raised questions that won't go away just from reassurances. The fact that Google controls both the browser and the ad industry means people have good reason to wonder whether the stated reasons are the whole story.

What happens next

Extensions still built on the old system will eventually stop working in Chrome. The path to switching to the new system exists. Some types of tools — password managers, developer tools, productivity software — adapt fairly easily. Ad blockers face the toughest job. Whether the new system's limits turn out to be good enough for real blocking, or whether Chrome users end up with weaker privacy protection, will become clear over the next several months of browser updates.

One important note: Firefox continues to support the old system, so if you're unhappy with how this plays out in Chrome, you have an alternative that isn't going anywhere soon.