Technology

Why California Rejected a Ban on Secret Recording With Smart Glasses

Martin HollowayPublished 2month ago2 min readBased on 4 sources
Reading level
Why California Rejected a Ban on Secret Recording With Smart Glasses
Photo by Office of the Lieutenant Governor of California / Public domain

California Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed SB-1130, a bill that would have made it illegal to secretly record people with smart glasses in certain places.

The veto was reported Oct. 1, 2026. The bill would have banned using a wearable to secretly record others in private areas inside businesses, including changing rooms and doctors' offices, according to contemporaneous reporting Engadget and AP.

The bill also set hardware rules. Makers of wearables would have had to add a light or sound that stays on during video or audio recording. It would also have banned selling technology made to hide that light or sound Engadget.

Punishment depended on who broke the rule. A person found guilty of secret recording faced up to $1,500 in fines and/or jail time. A company that made wearables without the signal, or made tools to block it, faced up to $2,500 per violation.

Newsom said the definition of wearable recording device was too broad. It could include certain smartwatches and other common worn devices used in public, causing confusion and unintended consequences. TechNet, an advocacy group representing tech companies, opposed the measure.

The device categories no longer hold. Microphones, cameras, cellular and Wi-Fi connections, and short-term storage on the device now appear across many wearables. Recording can be started by voice, gesture, phone app, or background routine. A future law must say whether it means any worn device that can record, only devices with certain sensors turned on, or only devices sold for first-person recording.

A required signal sounds simple, like the red light on a video camera. Lawmakers would still need to set how bright or loud it must be, how it acts in low-power modes, what happens if the light or speaker breaks, and when covering it counts as selling a cover-up tool. Because fines applied per violation, one design choice repeated across many units would add up fast.

In my view, lawmakers need to separate three issues SB-1130 combined. The first is secret recording where people expect privacy, which is about behavior. The second is letting bystanders know they may be recorded, which is about warning. The third is stopping deliberate defeat of that warning. A narrower ban for listed private spaces, plus a clear and testable rule for the signal, would be easier to build and test.

The broader context here helps explain what comes next. Clear and specific rules are easier to design to than broad categories that shift with each new sensor. The veto does not end pressure for rules on secret recording, but it shows California wants tighter wording before setting signal and fine rules across wearables. That leaves room for a narrower bill focused where privacy expectations are highest.