California Says No to a Ban on Secret Recording With Smart Glasses

California Gov. Gavin Newsom has vetoed Senate Bill 1130, which would have made it illegal to secretly record people with wearable recording devices. TechCrunch The bill was called the Wearable Device Privacy Protection Act. LexisNexis The veto was reported Oct. 1, 2026. It stopped what would have been the first state rule on smart glasses use. TechCrunch
SB 1130 was written by State Sen. Eloise Gómez Reyes. It would have barred recording in public places without clear permission. TechCrunch People who broke the rule could have faced fines or jail. Companies that make wearables and did not comply could also have faced fines. TechCrunch
Newsom gave two reasons for saying no. He said the bill defines wearable recording devices too broadly and vaguely, which could cause confusion and unintended consequences. He also said it includes protections that already exist in California law. TechCrunch
Reyes had described the bill as a way for California to respond to always-listening technology, devices that are always ready to hear or see. That concern matches public unease about wearables with cameras. Critics and consumers have called them "pervert glasses" after reports of people being recorded and harassed. TechCrunch
The broader context here is about wording, and wording decides if a law can work. A wearable recorder sounds like just glasses. In real life it can mean phones, glasses, pins, pendants and watches that capture sound, video, photos or other data. A wide law can punish normal uses too. A narrow law is easy to get around. This bill was wide, and enforcing it would have been messy.
Looking at what this means for builders, the problem is practical. If makers face fines, they need a clear rule to build to. What counts as recording. What counts as permission. How that permission is asked for, shown and saved. Without those answers, fights happen one by one in public places, where it is hard to prove what people knew. The burden would fall on users, reviewers, trust teams and courts, with little shared proof to settle it.
In my view, the veto does not settle the tension. Unease about secret recording is real. Clear permission is a simple idea that is hard to use in public. It is like asking everyone on a busy sidewalk to sign a permission slip. Any workable rule will need to separate background sensing from pressing record, and pressing record from sharing. It will also need to fit with current California privacy rules rather than repeat them in broader words.
For people who make and use these devices, the design questions are still open. A light that shows recording is happening, controls on who can watch, how long video is kept, and a record of who viewed it all affect trust. Clearer norms would help adoption more than either unlimited recording or a ban that cannot be enforced. The long arc still points to useful, everyday help from these devices, but only if the rules are clear to everyone in the room, not only the wearer.


