Why a Used PlayStation Now Costs More Than a New One

GameStop is listing a used PlayStation 5 Pro for $1,399.99. That is $500 more than Sony's new price of $899.99. The listing was reported on Oct. 10, 2026. Engadget
A used console normally costs less than a new one. Here it is the other way around. GameStop is not alone. Best Buy is selling the PS5 Pro for over $1,500. Walmart is selling a returned open-box version for $1,200. Used sales on eBay often go over $1,100. On GameStop's site, a new PS5 Pro is listed at $899.99, while used and fixed-up versions are listed at $1,329.99, and a used version with a disc drive at $1,424.99.
Sony's own prices show the gap. Sony lists the PS5 Pro at $899.99. That is $200 more than its first price when it came out in 2024. Engadget The regular PlayStation 5 with 1 TB of storage is $649.99. The Digital Edition with 825 GB is $599.99. PlayStation Blog The Pro has 2 TB of storage, can show games more smoothly at up to 120 images per second in sharp 4K detail, and can play more than 8,500 older PS4 games.
Supply is tight. In Japan, Sony is using a lottery tied to time spent playing games to decide who can buy a PS5 Pro. An August 2026 JPMorgan report predicted memory chip prices will have risen 400 percent worldwide by the end of 2026 since the PS5 Pro came out in 2024. In September 2026, Playfront reported on private messages between Sony and its sellers saying the shortage would last through early 2027 at the earliest. Engadget
The broader context here is where the real price is now set. Like sold-out concert tickets that go for more secondhand, when many stores sell used units for more than the new price, that new price becomes a starting point rather than the price most people pay. Part of the gap comes from higher memory costs and low supply. The rest comes from how the market works when goods are hard to find.
In my view, there is a longer point for everyday buyers. People will still pay $1,300 to $1,500 for a mid-life model with more storage and smoother play, even late in the console's life. A September 2025 report said GameStop Pro members were offered a used unit for $1,330, so this high price has lasted rather than come and gone quickly. Gamespot If supply improves after early 2027, prices should come down. Those owners will keep buying games and services, which is where the lasting value has usually grown.


