Ministers do not know cost of repairing England's maternity units, minister admits

The government does not know how much it would cost to upgrade maternity and neonatal units in England that need significant repair or replacement, NHS minister Karin Smyth has admitted. Neonatal units are the wards that care for newborn babies.
Liberal Democrat health spokesperson Helen Morgan accused ministers of gambling with the safety of mothers and babies over the unknown cost. Her criticism focused on the lack of a figure for work that has yet to be costed.
The scale of the problem was set out by NHS England, the body that runs the National Health Service (NHS) in England. It found that 43% of maternity and neonatal units did not meet basic safety standards because of poor infrastructure, meaning the buildings, equipment and physical systems they depend on. NHS England also said these infrastructure problems hampered the delivery of maternity clinical care thousands of times every year.
The Care Quality Commission warned that a lack of space, ageing facilities and a shortage of operating theatres present serious safety risks for mothers and babies.
The stakes are large. Over 1,500 babies are born in hospitals in England each day, and 1 in 7 of them needs specialist neonatal care, according to NHS England. NHS England's long-read report on maternity and neonatal infrastructure sets out the findings of a survey the health service committed to in 2023, as part of its three-year delivery plan for maternity and neonatal services.
That survey found that 42% of the maternity and neonatal estate needs major repair or replacement, and 7% is at serious risk of imminent breakdown. Over half of organisations reported the formal condition of their estate as unsatisfactory. The acute maternity and neonatal estate covers 831,739 square metres, and 57% of it is compliant in all four safety areas: electrical, water, fire safety and hazardous substances.
Problems with buildings have also disrupted care. In the last three years, 14,519 instances were formally reported in which maternity and neonatal clinical services were interrupted or affected by poor physical conditions. The estate-related problems behind lost clinical time include power outages, water leaks and faulty nurse call systems, and poor conditions can directly delay procedures such as planned caesarean sections.
Since the 2013 Maternity and Neonatal Health Building Note, 35% of these facilities have been refurbished, and 5% of that work included a new build element. The NHS estate as a whole carries a maintenance backlog of £13.8 billion, meaning repairs that have been identified but not yet carried out.


