Entertainment

James Middleton Locked in Planning Row Over Neighbour's Modern Home

Frances KelsallPublished 7m ago2 min readBased on 1 source
James Middleton Locked in Planning Row Over Neighbour's Modern Home
Image by Bittermuir from Pixabay

James Middleton, younger brother of Princess Catherine, is in a planning dispute with a neighbour over a proposed modern house opposite his home in Bucklebury, Berkshire, Hello! magazine reported on 16 November 2026.

Middleton has lived in a Grade II-listed farmhouse in the village since 2021, with his wife Alizée Thevenet and their son Inigo. A Grade II listing means the building is on the national register for its special architectural interest, which gives it legal protection. His parents, Michael and Carole Middleton, live at Bucklebury Manor a short distance away.

The new plan comes from David Alderton, who wants to build a super-modern, cubist-style house on a site across from the Middleton home. A planning application is a request to the local council for permission to build, and an appeal asks a higher decision-maker to look again after a refusal. The parish council, the local elected body for the village, has objected five times. It says the design is at odds with the tone of the village.

Middleton has hired planning consultant Lisa Jackson to challenge Alderton's latest appeal. Jackson argued that the design resembles a row of shops and is "alien in this landscape." Middleton himself said: "Many of us in the village think it's simply the wrong building for the site."

The row has also turned personal. Alderton accused Middleton's representative of presenting a "mendacious narrative", a term meaning deliberately misleading, and of making "false and disingenuous" claims about flooding on the site.

Middleton's objections go back further. In 2024, he accused Alderton of repeatedly trespassing on his land and contacted the police. Middleton has also complained that dozens of laminated posters attacking his mother's business, Party Pieces, which has collapsed, were stapled to trees in the village. Party Pieces sold party supplies.

In an email replying to Middleton's objection, Alderton reportedly wrote: "I'm up for the fight chap, hope you are, it's gonna get brutal."

Planning disputes like this one are usually settled through the local council and, where an appeal is lodged, a planning inspector appointed by the government.