Immigration officers missed risk signs in work visa decisions, review finds

Immigration officers missed "clear risk indicators" about whether migrants would leave New Zealand when their visas expired, according to a review of recent Accredited Employer Work Visa decisions, as reported by RNZ.
The review found gaps in some of the checks officers make on whether an applicant is genuine. These checks, known as bona fide assessments, test whether a person intends to leave once their visa ends. The review pointed to weak assessment of personal circumstances, stated intentions, incentives to comply with visa conditions, and plans for when no further visa is granted.
In several of the cases reviewed, officers relied heavily on whether the job offer was genuine and whether the applicant met the skills and experience requirements. They did not look at the wider picture where risk indicators were present.
Immigration New Zealand guidance tells officers to consider conditions in an applicant's home country. Officers should also check whether those conditions match patterns seen in asylum claims, which are requests for refugee status made after a person arrives in New Zealand. The guidance says officers should consider factors that could discourage a person from returning home. These include conflict, economic circumstances, religious persecution, gender persecution and patterns of asylum claims.
To establish strong ties to the home country, such as family and property ownership, officers can interview applicants or ask for documents. The guidance also says officers should examine any earlier work or travel in other countries, to judge whether the applicant previously followed visa requirements.
Immigration New Zealand wants officers to look more closely at applications from countries where war or persecution might lead to asylum claims after the person arrives.
The number of people seeking refugee recognition in New Zealand rose from about 500 in the years before the pandemic. It has been more than 2,000 in each year since the borders reopened.
Immigration Minister Erica Stanford said in March that there was a backlog of 4,000 asylum claims. She said the "vast majority" of them had no merit.


