Signal and Meta warn they may pull services from Canada over Bill C-22

Signal and Meta have warned Canadian senators that they would consider removing their secure messaging services from Canada if forced to weaken encryption under Bill C-22, Ottawa's lawful-access bill. The warnings came as the Globe and Mail reported on tech companies' efforts to have the bill changed.
Lawful access refers to rules that let police and intelligence agencies obtain access to electronic communications. Under Bill C-22, the federal government could require electronic service providers, including messaging apps, to change their systems so they can provide surveillance capabilities to police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, the federal spy agency. The bill would also let the Public Safety Minister issue ministerial orders to companies operating in Canada, and those orders would have to be kept secret.
The bill had already passed its House of Commons stages when the Senate heard the testimony. Rachel Curran, Meta Canada's head of public policy, told the Senate national security committee that Meta would not comply with an order forcing it to weaken encryption, the scrambling of messages so that only the sender and recipient can read them, on its platforms, which include WhatsApp. She said Meta would need to consider withdrawing affected services from Canada. She pointed to Apple's withdrawal of affected services in the United Kingdom after a technical assistance order.
Avery Pennarun, chief executive and co-founder of Tailscale, said the company has started looking into moving some secure communications services abroad because of Bill C-22. Executives from Tailscale and Beauceron Security were among the witnesses who asked senators to amend the bill. Tailscale provides end-to-end encrypted networking to millions of users worldwide, and more than 50,000 businesses use its technology. The company has more than 300 employees, about 40 per cent of them in Canada.


