Entertainment

The Fantasticks Opens on Broadway for the First Time, With a Boy-Meets-Boy Story

Lorna HartiganPublished 5m ago2 min readBased on 2 sources
The Fantasticks Opens on Broadway for the First Time, With a Boy-Meets-Boy Story
Photo by Hossein Nasr on Unsplash

The Fantasticks is on Broadway for the first time, and this new production changes the show's central romance. The Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt musical has been reimagined as a love story between two boys, according to Deadline, which reviewed the production on November 17, 2026.

The show ran Off Broadway, the smaller theaters outside the main Broadway district, for a total of 42 years. This is its first run in the Broadway theaters. Christopher Gattelli directs the revival, which means a new staging of a show that has been performed before.

In the original, two young people named Matt and Luisa fall in love while their fathers feud. In this version, the youths are Matt and Lewis, and the feuding parents are mothers. Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy play the two boys. Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles play the mothers.

Zane Phillips plays El Gallo, the schemer who sets the plot in motion. The supporting cast includes David Patrick Kelly, Kevin del Aguila and Ahmad Simmons.

The music is familiar to many audiences. The score includes "Try to Remember," "Much More," "Soon It's Gonna Rain" and "I Can See It." Sam Davis wrote new orchestrations, the arrangements that decide which instruments play each song. The original sound relied on piano and harp. This version adds strings, woodwinds and brass.

Deadline's review also notes that the production's onstage trunks are labeled "Hayes Theater" and "Sullivan Street Playhouse." Those names point to the show's history in New York. The Sullivan Street Playhouse was one of the Off-Broadway homes where the show ran for decades.

A Broadway opening is also a business event. A show's backers put up the money to open the doors, and they usually hope to recoup, meaning the show has finally earned back what it cost to open. Its ticket sales, running costs and capitalization are not known.

For a first-time theatergoer, the practical point is simple. This revival is a new production of an old show, with a new cast and a different sound. Anyone who knows the original will hear the familiar songs in a new setting. Anyone who has never seen the show will get a new version of a story the stage has been telling since the 1960s.

Broadway shows arrive and leave on a steady schedule. This one has now made its way into the Broadway houses after more than four decades Off Broadway.