Entertainment

Sotheby's Settles Fischer Heirs' Claim to Van Gogh Before Auction

Hoi-Ling MakPublished 8m ago2 min readBased on 1 source
Sotheby's Settles Fischer Heirs' Claim to Van Gogh Before Auction
Photo by Vincent van Gogh / Public domain

A Van Gogh painting due to lead a major sale this week has been cleared of a family claim. The auction house Sotheby's said on Tuesday that the owners, the Blaquier-Arrieta family, had reached a settlement with all the legal descendants of Hedwig and Samuel Fischer.

The painting is Vincent van Gogh's Châtaigniers en fleurs, which he made in 1890. The Blaquier-Arrieta family has owned it since 1975. Sotheby's valued it at US$180 million before the sale, and it was set to open the auction house's US$450 million sale of the family's collection. ArtNews reported the settlement and the valuation.

The Fischer heirs argued that the family was forced to sell the picture in Amsterdam in 1936. They said financial pressure caused by Nazi persecution left them little choice. Gunnar Schnabel, a Berlin lawyer representing the heirs, had demanded that Sotheby's withdraw the work unless it could show the 1936 sale was voluntary.

Sotheby's answered with records from the Paul Cassirer archive. Those records show the painting sold in June 1936 for 68,000 Swiss francs, roughly US$22,000 at the time. The auction house said that price was fair for a van Gogh in that period, and that the picture had been in Amsterdam for almost three years before it was sold.

The settlement now clears the way for the painting to go under the hammer on Wednesday night. The hammer price is the bid the auctioneer closes on, before buyer's fees are added. Sotheby's said the agreement means the buyer will receive clear title, meaning legal ownership with no competing claims. The auction house said the deal recognised both the painting's complicated history and the persecution the Fischer family suffered under the Nazis.

Sotheby's has not disclosed the terms of the settlement. It has not said what, if anything, the Fischer heirs received.

The claim carries a personal thread. Gisela Bermann Fischer spent years pursuing the return of artworks her family lost during the Nazi era. She died in 2014. In 2007, she declined to oppose the sale of a Paul Cézanne work that had passed through the same Amsterdam dealer. She did, however, reserve her right to challenge other sales.

For the families and staff who prepare major sales, a settled title is what allows a painting to be shown, insured and sold on schedule. Each step in that process, from crating to the sale room, depends on whether the paperwork is in order. This week, that paperwork has been agreed by the parties to the claim, and the auction can go ahead.