UK Tribunal Rejects Collective Claim Over PlayStation Store Pricing

A UK Competition Appeal Tribunal has dismissed a collective action alleging that Sony's control of the PlayStation Store inflated game prices. The judgment, dated 17 November 2026, carries the neutral citation [2026] CAT 86, according to the Competition Appeal Tribunal's judgments register.
The proceedings, case number 1527/7/7/22, are captioned Alex Neill Class Representative Limited v Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe Limited, Sony Interactive Entertainment Network Europe Limited and Sony Interactive Entertainment UK Limited. Consumer advocate Alex Neill brought the claim in 2022 on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners. It sought £2 billion ($2.6 billion) in damages.
The claimant's case rested on two figures. The suit alleged that Sony's control of the store enabled a 30 percent cut on digital sales, meaning the share of each sale the platform keeps, and that game prices would be about 20 percent cheaper without Sony's practices. Had the claim succeeded, eligible consumers could have received around £162 ($214) each, as Engadget reported.
Sony's defence centred on the engineering and economics of the platform. It argued that supporting third-party storefronts would be prohibitively expensive, and that opening the platform would diminish security and performance.
The tribunal did not accept the case as framed. It ruled that players had alternatives to PlayStation Store games, namely physical copies and rival consoles. It called the argument that players were trapped in a closed ecosystem “not credible”, and it rejected the claim that games would have been 20 percent cheaper absent Sony's practices.
The tribunal also found strong evidence that consumers were willing to switch consoles after an increase in game prices. It cited Sony research warning that the company would lose business if its prices were not competitive with Xbox's.
The same tribunal ruled against Apple in a similar case, finding that the App Store's 30 percent cut on digital sales was an abuse of dominance, a competition-law term for a firm with market power using it improperly. The two judgments therefore reach opposite conclusions on a commission rate of the same size, and the difference is worth examining closely.
The broader context here is market definition. Both cases turn on whether a platform owner's digital storefront is a market in its own right, or whether physical media, rival hardware and the wider console market discipline its pricing. Think of a shopping centre that takes a cut of every sale made by the shops inside it. The question is whether that centre competes only with itself, or with every other way of buying the same thing. In the Sony case, the tribunal treated the console purchase as the point where competition takes place, and found that switching hardware was a credible constraint on store pricing. The Apple ruling shows that the same question can be answered differently depending on the evidence about the relevant market and the switching costs faced by developers and users.
In my view, the practical lesson for platform operators is that commission structures will be tested against the alternatives available to consumers at the point of purchase, rather than against the closed nature of the ecosystem alone. For developers and publishers, the Sony judgment suggests that competition between console makers can act as a meaningful check on storefront fees, while the Apple ruling shows that the check is not automatic. For consumers, the verdict leaves intact the choice between buying digitally on one platform and buying physically or on a rival console, which is the choice the tribunal found they already had.
The outcome closes one collective route to damages, but it does not settle how commission levels on digital storefronts will be treated across platforms in the UK. Those questions now rest on the evidentiary record that each tribunal finds persuasive.


