Entertainment

Labels Push Back on Suno's Bid to Freeze Second AI Copyright Lawsuit

Kiran MachadoPublished 19m ago2 min readBased on 1 source
Labels Push Back on Suno's Bid to Freeze Second AI Copyright Lawsuit
Image by Didgeman from Pixabay

Universal Music Group and Sony Music Entertainment are opposing an attempt by Suno, an AI music generator, to put their second copyright lawsuit on hold. The labels say a full pause could keep that case frozen until 2028, as Music Business Worldwide reported on November 17, 2026.

In papers filed on November 13 in federal court in Boston, the labels argued that under Suno's plan, its 2025 and 2026 models and its business conduct would be examined nowhere until at least 2028. They named the v6 model suite, launched in September, as one of the products that would be affected.

The dispute goes back to June 2024, when Universal, Sony and Warner Music Group sued Suno. Warner settled and struck a licensing deal with the company in November 2025. The first case now covers 560 of Universal and Sony's recordings. Suno's main defence there is fair use, a legal doctrine that allows some use of copyrighted material without permission. Suno argues that training its AI on copyrighted recordings without a licence is lawful.

On October 30, Suno asked Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV to pause the second case until he rules on summary judgment in the first. A summary judgment ruling is a decision made on the written evidence, without a trial. Suno argued that if the judge sides with it on fair use, or on the stream-ripping claim involving YouTube, the first case could shut down the labels' arguments in the second.

The second lawsuit, filed on September 18, accuses Suno of copying 60,202 of the labels' recordings without a licence to train its AI models. The labels are asking the court to order Suno to stop any further use of their recordings. US copyright law caps statutory damages for willful infringement at $150,000 per work, a fixed amount a court can award without proof of exact losses.

The labels have offered to delay proving ownership of the more than 60,000 recordings until Judge Saylor rules on the first case. That offer is a sign of how closely the two cases are tied together.

The first case is moving on a set timetable. Fact discovery, the stage where each side gathers evidence from the other, has largely closed on the infringement claims. Discovery on the stream-ripping claim runs until November 20, 2026. Summary judgment motions are due by June 22, 2027.

For the people who make and sell recordings, the timing matters as much as the legal argument. The labels want the courts to act on their recordings now, while Suno wants the second case to wait for the first. Judge Saylor has the pause request in front of him.