Melbourne architect urges Victoria to refurbish, not demolish, public housing towers

Simon Robinson, director of Office, a Melbourne not-for-profit research and design practice, wants the Victorian state government to rethink its plan to pull down every one of the city's public housing towers. He says fixing them up is the smarter choice. Dezeen, the design news website, published his comments from an interview on 17 November 2026.
The towers were built between 1962 and 1975. Victoria, the Australian state that includes Melbourne, is running a plan called the High-Rise Redevelopment Program. The Labor government announced it in 2023. Under the plan, all 44 towers will be razed, meaning knocked down, and replaced by 2051.
Victorian officials say the program will triple housing capacity and improve the quality of the homes. Robinson disagrees with the route. He argues for retrofit, which means upgrading an existing building rather than replacing it, combined with infill, which means adding new homes in the spaces between existing ones.
Office estimates that this approach would cost around $300 million less than demolishing and rebuilding. A large part of the saving, the firm says, comes from not having to move residents out while the work is done.
Office took on the work for free, or pro bono, to make the case for refurbishing the towers. The team began after learning that the government had not published feasibility studies for keeping the condemned estates. A feasibility study is a formal check on whether a project can be done, and what it would cost.
For the people who live in the towers, the question is where they would be during any rebuild, and whether they would return. Robinson's proposal is built around keeping them in place. The government's plan, by contrast, is built around replacing the towers with new housing over the next two decades.
Office is a research and design practice, which means its work is about studying how buildings and neighbourhoods function as well as designing new ones. Its intervention in the debate is an unusual one: a design firm putting a costed alternative on the table after the state government's own studies were not made public.


