Entertainment

Cologne auction house still plans to sell two disputed Koerbecke panels

Hoi-Ling MakPublished 3m ago2 min readBased on 4 sources
Cologne auction house still plans to sell two disputed Koerbecke panels
source:lempertz.com

Lempertz, an auction house in Cologne, says it still plans to sell two paintings by the Gothic artist Johann Koerbecke on Saturday, 21 November. The heirs of a German-Jewish art dealer say the works were stolen from him.

The two panels are The Annunciation and The Vision of Saint Bernard. They are thought to come from the Marienfeld high altarpiece, completed in 1457. Each carries a high estimate of around €300,000, about US$329,000. An estimate is the price range an auction house expects a work to reach. Those two estimates are the highest in Lempertz's Old Masters sale. The lot entries say the panels, numbered 1005 and 1006, will first be offered one at a time and then together, for art historical reasons. ARTnews reported the sale details.

The dealer is Max Stern. He held both paintings in Düsseldorf in 1936 and 1937, the year the Nazis closed his gallery. The two works were once opposite sides of a single panel. Stern had separated them, hoping to sell each one on its own.

Before Stern, the paintings belonged to Ellen Funke. The Nazis classed her as a Mischling, the term they used for people with partly Jewish ancestry. In her case the Jewish ancestry came through her mother. In 1936 Funke sold her collection to pay for leaving Germany. Her heirs are listed as the sellers of both works on Lempertz's website.

The claims against the sale run in two directions. Both paintings have appeared in the Interpol Database of Stolen Art, the international police register of stolen cultural objects, since 2021. The German Lost Art Database lists both as Nazi-confiscated property. The Dr. Max and Iris Stern Foundation registered that claim in 2018. The foundation has asked Lempertz to stop the sale until two separate ownership claims are settled under the Washington Principles, a set of 1998 guidelines on returning art seized by the Nazis.

Both works have already been returned once. In 2025, Bavaria's state museums gave The Vision of Saint Bernard back to Funke's heirs. The Kolumba Art Museum, run by the Archdiocese of Cologne, had received The Annunciation as a donation in 1996. It also handed that painting back in 2025.

For the Funke heirs and the Stern Foundation, the dispute is about who has the right to the panels. For Lempertz, the auction goes ahead as planned unless something changes. Buyers will see the works on the block on Saturday, if the sale proceeds.