Sports

Prendergast cleared for South Africa match after tackle ruling

Carys BevanPublished 9m ago2 min readBased on 1 source
Prendergast cleared for South Africa match after tackle ruling
Photo by Stefano Delfrate / CC BY-SA 2.0

Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast is cleared to play against South Africa on Saturday in the Nations Championship, after a panel ruled his tackle on Fiji was not worthy of a red card. BBC Sport reported the decision.

The fly-half is the player who directs the attack from behind the scrum and usually does the kicking. Prendergast is 23. His tackle on Fiji flanker Peceli Yato came in the first half. He wrapped his body around the back of Yato's legs, and the tackle drew attention straight away.

Nobody sent him off on the pitch. Later, a citing commissioner, an official who reviews incidents after the match and can refer them for a hearing, flagged the tackle for retrospective review. It was a hip-drop tackle, a type that World Rugby outlawed before the November internationals. Ireland argued that the tackle did not meet the threshold for a red card, meaning a sending-off, and the panel agreed.

South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus had predicted that Prendergast would escape punishment on a "technicality". Erasmus is himself in the spotlight. He has been banned for six Tests after comments about match officials. World Rugby said his words were "an unacceptable attack on the credibility and competence of the match officials".

The row also touches on how video referees work. Television match officials, the officials who check incidents on screen, have been asked to interrupt a match only for clear and obvious foul play. Those guidelines were agreed under protocols with head coaches, including Erasmus.

For the Ireland squad, the outcome means the 23-year-old is free to start on Saturday. For South Africa, it leaves a sharp debate about what counts as a serious enough tackle to stop a game, and who gets to decide. Both questions will still be there when the whistle goes.