Guardian Calls Nicolas Cage's Madden Biopic a Stinker

The Guardian has called Madden a stinker. In its review, published November 18, 2026, the paper says the Amazon biopic, directed by David O Russell, cannot decide whether it wants to be serious or slapstick.
The film stars Nicolas Cage as John Madden, the former coach and broadcaster whose name became the title of the long-running EA Sports football video game. Christian Bale plays Al Davis, the longtime leader of the Oakland Raiders. Sienna Miller plays Carol Davis, the Raiders' first lady, and Kathryn Hahn plays Virginia, Madden's wife. John Mulaney plays Trip Hawkins of EA Sports, the company that makes the game.
The Guardian's reviewer goes harder on the portrait than on the cast list. The review describes the film as a disservice to Madden and a thin caricature of the man. It is a blunt verdict for a story about one of the most recognizable voices in American football.
Casting was a story before the cameras rolled. Will Ferrell passed on the lead role before Cage was cast, according to the Guardian's review.
Why it matters for football fans is easy to see. Madden spent decades explaining the game on Sunday broadcasts, drawing plays on a telestrator and turning complicated formations into plain talk. A biopic that misses that voice leaves a gap that many viewers will feel. The review suggests the film spends more energy on spectacle and gags than on the football mind that made him famous.
For anyone who grew up with Madden on the television or on the couch with a controller, the reviewer's verdict is the headline. Whether a general audience will agree with it is a question the review cannot answer, and the film will have to find its own viewers.
The Guardian's review is not kind.


