Entertainment

Cascio siblings sue lawyer over 2019 deal with Michael Jackson's estate

Kiran MachadoPublished 3m ago3 min readBased on 1 source
Cascio siblings sue lawyer over 2019 deal with Michael Jackson's estate
Photo by The Jackson 5 / Public domain

Five siblings who say Michael Jackson groomed and sexually abused them as children have sued the entertainment lawyer who helped bring them into a 2019 agreement with Jackson's estate. Rolling Stone first reported the malpractice lawsuit, filed in Los Angeles County Superior Court against attorney Bryan Freedman.

The plaintiffs are Frank Cascio and his siblings Dominic, Marie-Nicole, Edward and Aldo. They allege that Jackson abused them when they were minors, and that they first met him through their father, who worked at a luxury hotel the pop star often visited. Their lawyer in the new case is Howard King.

Legal malpractice is a claim that a lawyer failed to meet the professional duty owed to a client, causing harm. Here, the siblings say Freedman persuaded them to sign an agreement that was unconscionable, a legal term for a deal so one-sided that a court may refuse to enforce it.

According to the lawsuit, the deal was presented as a purchase of the rights to the siblings' life stories. In practice, the siblings say, it barred them from publicly discussing Jackson's alleged abuse. It also released the estate from liability for allegedly facilitating or concealing that abuse.

The payment terms were set out clearly. The estate was to make five annual payments of $690,000 (in US dollars) to each sibling. Any dispute had to go to mandatory arbitration, a private process in which an arbitrator decides the outcome instead of a judge and jury. The lawsuit also alleges a penalty clause. If one family member disclosed Jackson's alleged crimes, the entire Cascio family would have to return all payments.

The siblings say Freedman had conflicts they did not know about. According to the complaint, he was already representing Edward Cascio and Marie-Nicole's husband in separate legal matters when the 2019 agreement was signed. The siblings allege he assured them he was acting in their best interests, discouraged them from hiring their own lawyers, and kept the conflict hidden.

The siblings further allege that Jackson's estate brought Freedman in to stop more accusers from coming forward. They link this to the fallout from Leaving Neverland, the 2019 documentary in which two men described abuse by Jackson. The lawsuit says Freedman later returned in 2024, called the original agreement "toilet paper," and told them the estate wanted to make more payments because it had not paid them enough.

The malpractice complaint also includes claims of breach of fiduciary duty, meaning a duty to put a client's interests first; fraud; and negligent misrepresentation, which covers false statements made without proper care.

The case is one part of a longer legal fight. The siblings have hired a different lawyer to challenge the 2019 agreement as void and unconscionable. Earlier, in February, they filed a child sex trafficking lawsuit, which was ordered into arbitration in August.

Jackson died in 2009 and has never been charged with the abuse the siblings describe. The new lawsuit makes allegations only, and the claims have not been tested in court.