Politics

Court rules pay equity changes breached women's rights

Hana SinclairPublished just now2 min readBased on 1 source
Court rules pay equity changes breached women's rights
Photo by Doug Mountain / CC0

The High Court has ruled that the Government breached women's rights by scrapping dozens of pay equity claims and making it harder to lodge future ones, according to RNZ.

Pay equity claims are cases in which workers argue that jobs dominated by women are undervalued and should be paid more. Justice Paul Radich held that the tightening of the Equal Pay Act, the law on pay discrimination between men and women, discriminated against women. He also found the tightening was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, which sets out basic rights in New Zealand law.

Justice Radich found that women in undervalued, female-dominated jobs were subject to unjustified discrimination because of their sex. He found that the Equal Pay Act changes were driven mainly by a desire to save money on settling pay equity claims, rather than to fix a broken system.

Five unions, including the Public Service Association, took legal action against the law change. The bill was rushed through Parliament under urgency, a fast-track process that limits debate. The court rejected the unions' argument that passing the changes without consultation breached rights, finding there is no legal requirement to consult before a bill is introduced.

The declaration does not revoke the amended law or restore the pay equity claims that were extinguished. The next New Zealand government must issue a formal response to the declaration, and MPs would then debate that response.

Responsible minister Brooke van Velden said the Crown was still considering whether to appeal the High Court decision.