Newsmax Sues to Block Fox's Roku Deal, Citing Free Streaming Power

Newsmax has filed an antitrust lawsuit asking a court to block Fox's deal for Roku, the company behind the streaming devices and TV platform used in millions of homes. Antitrust law is the set of rules that stops one company from gaining unfair control of a market. According to Variety, the complaint was filed in federal court in Northern California.
The deal has already gone through in one sense. Fox Corp. closed its $22 billion acquisition of Roku. The U.S. Department of Justice, the government body that reviews large mergers, had cleared it. As part of that clearance, Fox made commitments to keep Roku an "open and neutral" platform, meaning one that treats rival channels and services evenly.
Newsmax says those promises cannot be enforced. Its complaint argues the deal gives Fox unlawful monopoly power over free streaming television, the kind you watch without paying a subscription and that is funded by advertising. The lawsuit alleges Fox will control some 70% of that market through its ownership of Roku and of Tubi, Fox's free streaming service.
The complaint also says Fox has refused to carry Newsmax on Tubi. Newsmax is a news channel, and carrying a channel means offering its programmes to viewers on a service. Fox has not, in the reporting so far, responded to that specific point in detail.
Fox has pushed back hard. A Fox spokesperson said Newsmax's complaint is "wholly without merit," which is a way of saying the company considers the claims baseless.
This is not the first time Newsmax has taken Fox to court. Last year, Newsmax filed a separate antitrust suit against Fox in federal court in Florida, over how its channel reaches viewers through cable and satellite providers. Judge Aileen Cannon dismissed that case as an impermissible "shotgun" pleading, a term for a legal filing that throws too many claims together without making clear which ones apply to whom. Newsmax then refiled its claims in Wisconsin. A judge there granted Fox's request to move the case back to Florida.
Christopher Ruddy, the chief executive of Newsmax, is the company's public face in this dispute. The new complaint is a claim, not a ruling. The court has not yet decided whether the Fox-Roku deal should be blocked, and Fox's position is that it should not be.
For viewers, the story sits in a crowded corner of the business. Free ad-supported channels have grown into a major way people watch television, and the companies that control the screens and the channel lineups have real influence over what appears where. Whether that influence is a problem under antitrust law is the question the court now has to weigh.


