Entertainment

Documentary Makers Warned to Read the AI Fine Print on Archive Deals

Jonah VillalbaPublished 3m ago2 min readBased on 1 source
Documentary Makers Warned to Read the AI Fine Print on Archive Deals
Image by carmen_carbonell from Pixabay

Documentary makers are being courted to sell their archive footage for artificial intelligence training, and one rights executive says the taking has gone on for years. Wendy Bernfield, chief executive of Rights Stuff, told Variety that AI has been scraping or stealing documentary material for more than three years.

The question has been on the festival agenda too. The International Documentary Film Festival Amsterdam (IDFA) ran an industry talk titled "Is AI Stealing My Documentary?" The festival had already seen the idea tested on screen. Piotr Winiewicz's documentary About a Hero opened IDFA in 2024, and it explored whether an AI model could conceive a Werner Herzog film.

The buyers are not always household names. AI aggregators, services that bundle the output of several AI models behind one interface, number around 15, according to Variety. Only a few of them are dedicated full-time to harvesting archival images. Bernfield spent six months interviewing aggregators and reading what they put in their contracts.

Those contracts are where filmmakers can lose ground. Variety reports that a Canadian filmmaker found an opt-out clause for training use that gave them just five days to refuse. It took several months to get the clause changed. An opt-out clause is a term that lets a rights holder say no, so a five-day window leaves little room to think.

Elizabeth Klinck, an archive producer at E Klinck Research, said she is approached just about every week by filmmakers about AI companies that want to acquire their material. Her advice was to plan for disputes before they arrive. She warned that archive-based films may not hold up for errors and omissions insurance, the cover producers buy against legal claims over a film's content, or for copyright clearances, the permissions needed to use other people's material.

The debate also reaches filmmakers' own work. Ava DuVernay has admitted to using AI in the Netflix documentary 14th, where it was used to animate archival photographs that are in the public domain, meaning no copyright applies to them.

For documentary makers, the practical lesson is in the paperwork. Anyone approached by an AI buyer is being asked to read those terms first.