World

Inquest in northern NSW examines four baby deaths linked to home and free births

Elena MarquezPublished just now2 min readBased on 1 source
Inquest in northern NSW examines four baby deaths linked to home and free births
Image by LVER from Pixabay

A coroner's inquest at Lismore, in New South Wales, Australia, is examining the deaths of four babies born at home or in free births in the state's northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024, according to The Guardian.

The four babies are referred to in the inquest as Baby R, Baby D, Baby DH and Baby B. Baby R, Baby D and Baby DH died after free births, which are births planned without a medical professional present. Baby B's case differs from the other three, and the inquest has heard most of its detail about the pregnancy and birth in that case.

Baby B's mother was expecting twins. She did not want a hospital birth after hearing about other women's traumatic birth experiences. She had scans at 12 and 22 weeks but declined hospital antenatal care and a consultation with an obstetrician.

Her midwife recommended monthly ultrasounds and induction of labour at 36 to 37 weeks, and the mother declined both. The midwife warned her about the risks at every visit, according to the inquest's account. Her birth plan included four midwives.

Baby B died of a bacterial infection. The other twin became ill but survived.

Professor Hannah Dahlen, an expert witness, said home birth was unsuitable for this pregnancy. She pointed to several factors: it was a twin pregnancy that had gone beyond 41 weeks without specialist review, the home was far from a hospital, and an urgent operative birth, meaning a surgical delivery, might have been needed. She also noted that two babies could require skilled care and resuscitation at the same time.

Expert opinion found that the midwives' treatment in Baby B's case was reasonable and appropriate. That finding sets it apart from the other three births examined at the inquest.

Local hospital staff, obstetricians, a GP and the ambulance service worked together to prepare for Baby B's planned home birth. Among the preparations, they organised a second paediatric resuscitation kit, a set of equipment for reviving babies.