World

Consultant calls for police investigation after 19 deaths at Aberdeen hospital

Elena MarquezPublished 4m ago3 min readBased on 1 source
Consultant calls for police investigation after 19 deaths at Aberdeen hospital
Photo by Javid Hashimov on Pexels

Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, has called for a criminal police investigation into the hospital after at least 19 patients died from avoidable complications arising from surgery, according to The Guardian.

Habib said he had repeatedly raised concerns about liver and pancreatic surgery at the hospital from 2021 onwards. He believes dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily there. He has called for a police inquiry into corporate homicide, a legal term for deaths caused by an organisation's failures, and alleged that senior officials at NHS Grampian, the health board responsible for the hospital, did not take correct action quickly enough.

NHS Grampian commissioned an expert report into the allegations made by Habib and a second whistleblower, a staff member who raises concerns about their workplace. That report confirmed that 19 patients died due to "serious adverse events" caused by surgery between 2015 and 2021. Aamer Anwar, Habib's solicitor, published the internal expert report on Thursday.

An earlier review, completed in 2022, was carried out by two external experts who are surgery professors at the universities of Edinburgh and Leeds. It concluded that the death rate in liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen between 2017 and 2020 was "extremely high", at up to 18%. The national average for deaths in these operations is 2 to 3%, depending on the condition of the patient.

In March 2026, another external expert told hospital executives it was imperative that surgery end at Aberdeen. That expert described "persistent high mortality in complex surgery" as a red-flag indicator of systemic failure. The liver and pancreatic surgery department was shut down after that warning.

Scotland's First Minister, John Swinney, said Habib's disclosures were "of the gravest concern" during a discussion in the Scottish Parliament at Holyrood on Thursday. Michael Marra, leader of Scottish Labour, demanded a criminal investigation into systemic failures at NHS Grampian. He said the families of the 19 people who died deserve answers and justice.

Swinney rejected the demands for a criminal investigation. He said that leadership changes and urgent reforms at NHS Grampian should produce the necessary improvements.