Sports

Judges Weigh Whether Hundreds of Rugby Concussion Claims Can Go On

Carys BevanPublished 3m ago3 min readBased on 1 source
Judges Weigh Whether Hundreds of Rugby Concussion Claims Can Go On
Photo by Thiago Sepulveda on Pexels

Two senior judges have retired to decide whether hundreds of former rugby players can keep pursuing claims that the sport's governing bodies failed to protect them from brain injury. The Guardian reports that Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter heard two days of argument at the Royal Courts of Justice in London before going away to think it over.

The players allege that they suffer neurological damage caused by the professional negligence of World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union (RFU), the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) and the Rugby Football League. Negligence, in legal terms, means a failure to take reasonable care. The defendants deny liability, and the claims have not been tested in court.

The hearing was meant to pick a shortlist of test cases. These are a small number of individual claims that go to trial first, with the outcome intended to guide the rest of the group. Instead, much of the time was taken up with a argument over disclosure, which means handing over relevant documents to the other side. Lawyers call the consequences of failing to do so "striking out", where a claim is removed from the court.

All 378 claimants in the rugby union case, and most of the 173 in the rugby league case, had been struck out after their previous law firm failed to disclose relevant documents. The claimants now have a chance to come back in, a process known as relief from sanctions. The Senior Master gave that relief on condition that their current firm, KP Law, put its disclosure in order by 30 October.

KP Law says it has since provided 2,000 more documents and has asked the court for an extension until January to hand over the rest. Its lead barrister, Paul Downes KC, a senior barrister who acts as an advocate in the most serious cases, described the work of the previous firm, Rylands Garth, as "shambolic". Mr Downes also told the court that 39 players, 22 from union and 17 from league, were substantially in compliance with court orders.

The defendants were not sympathetic to a long wait. Nina Goolamali KC, for World Rugby, argued that the proposed trial date of October 2028 could not be met given the disclosure delays. Neil Block KC, for the RFU, said a trial in that month would be impossible. Michael Kent KC, for the WRU, told the court the case had become bogged down in an endless debate about disclosure. Counsel for all three bodies argued that the cases should stand as struck out.

What happens next is for the judges to decide. Their ruling will determine whether the claims continue, and if they do, which cases go forward first. For players who have waited years to have their injuries examined in court, the decision will matter a great deal, whichever way it goes.