Musk Defends Nvidia Staff Loyalty to Huang as Reporting Describes a Management Style Built on Fear

Elon Musk, asked about Jensen Huang's ouster at the DealBook conference in New York, said of Nvidia employees regarding Huang: "They love him. They love him." The remark came as reporting on Huang's management style drew scrutiny of how he led the company's staff.
Musk also compared the ouster to kicking Michael Jordan off the Chicago Bulls roster during Jordan's historic run. TechCrunch reported the comparison.
Thousands of Nvidia employees signed a letter asking for Huang's return.
The New York Times reported that Huang ruled through praise and fear and by humiliating people. TechCrunch summarized that reporting. According to the account, Huang told subordinates that Nvidia's wealth made it impossible to motivate them with money, so humiliation was the only lever left. In management terms, a lever is any tool for changing how people behave, such as pay or rewards.
The reporting also states that Huang reportedly told one executive his mother should have aborted him. He reportedly told another employee he would rip his arms off and beat him to death with them.
The account includes a 2005 episode involving Michael Winston, then Nvidia's head of human resources. Winston reportedly threatened to sue and called Huang's conduct the most abusive he had seen. Nvidia paid Winston more than $1 million.
A spokesman for Huang called the allegations about his conduct fabrications.
The broader context here is the gap between two accounts of the same leader. Musk's remarks and the employee letter describe a workforce that admires Huang. The reporting describes a management method built on fear, and it names a former senior HR executive who objected to that conduct nearly two decades ago.
In my view, the more useful question for engineers and managers is not whether a charismatic founder can drive results through intensity. It is what happens to the people who work under that intensity, and whether the organization can separate the loyalty it inspires from the fear it reportedly relies on. The reported conduct is serious.


