Entertainment

Part of Trump's Lucky Loser Defamation Suit Can Go to Trial

Quiana BaptistePublished 5m ago2 min readBased on 1 source
Part of Trump's Lucky Loser Defamation Suit Can Go to Trial
Photo by Shealeah Craighead / Public domain

A federal judge in Florida has ruled that part of Donald Trump's defamation lawsuit over the book Lucky Loser can go forward to trial. Four of the case's claims will proceed, and two have been dismissed. The ruling was reported by Publishers Marketplace on 20 November 2026.

A defamation suit argues that someone published false statements that damaged a person's reputation. Each separate claim in a lawsuit is called a count, so a judge can keep some and throw out others.

The case names four defendants: Penguin Random House, the publisher; The New York Times; and Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, the authors of Lucky Loser. That means the claims reach beyond the two writers to the publishing house and the newspaper.

Judge Steven D. Merryday's decision turned on the meaning of "actual malice". This legal test comes from the 1964 US Supreme Court case New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. Under it, a public figure who sues over false statements must show that the publisher knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for whether it was true.

The judge also questioned whether Buettner and Craig sought enough guidance from experts when they analysed Trump's finances. Expert guidance here means advice from specialists in the subject matter, such as accountants or financial analysts, before reaching conclusions.

For now, four counts will be tested in court, and the two dismissed counts are out of the case. Anyone who reads a nonfiction book about a public figure is, in a small way, reading a claim that a court may one day examine line by line. The case shows how a published account can be tested in court long after it reaches the shelves.