Entertainment

Before the Gloves: The Studio Push to Replace Stallone in Rocky

Jonah VillalbaPublished 9m ago2 min readBased on 1 source
Before the Gloves: The Studio Push to Replace Stallone in Rocky
Photo by M Sides on Pexels

Before Sylvester Stallone became Rocky Balboa on screen, the studio wanted someone else. According to Variety, United Artists offered Stallone up to $250,000 to step aside from starring in "Rocky", and the studio preferred James Caan, Nick Nolte or Ryan O'Neal for the lead.

That negotiation is now on screen. "I Play Rocky" is in theatres in 2026, marking 50 years since "Rocky" premiered. The film follows Stallone as he writes the script, stars in it and watches it win the Best Picture Oscar. Anthony Ippolito plays Stallone.

The film also revisits one of the best-known parts of the story: how fast the script came together. Stallone sketched the basics during 72 hours of day-and-night work, with his wife typing up his handwritten lines. Variety reports that the script was not finished in those three days. He sketched about the first third, then made dozens of revisions.

Producers Robert Chartoff and Irwin Winkler were the ones who negotiated with Stallone over whether he would play the lead. Their talks took place while the studio was pressing for other actors, and the film dramatises that tug of war.

Casting fights like this one usually stay behind closed doors. Here, the argument over who should play the boxer is part of the film's own storyline, and it runs alongside the story of a screenplay that took many drafts to reach its final form.

Fifty years on, the film puts the deal-making in front of audiences, showing that the role of Rocky was not settled until the people involved fought over it.