Judge Refuses to Dismiss Bich Heirs' Fra Angelico Lawsuit

A New York judge has refused to throw out a lawsuit by the sons of Bruno Bich over a painting by Fra Angelico, so the case will move forward.
Justice James G. Clynes of the New York Supreme Court, the state's main trial court, issued the decision. It is dated October 26 and was filed on November 16, according to ArtNews.
The painting is Saint Sixtus, made around 1453 to 1455 by the Italian Renaissance painter Fra Angelico. Baron Marcel Bich bought it at Sotheby's, the London auction house, in 1972 for £130,000.
Bruno Bich's three sons, Gonzalve, Charles and Guillaume, filed the lawsuit in March 2026. They allege that Roy Morrow, the family's chauffeur, stole the painting and sold it to the New York art dealer Richard Feigen for US$3 million.
The painting later went to auction. Feigen consigned it to Christie's, the auction house, where it sold in 2018 for US$5.4 million to Alvaro Saieh and Ana Guzman.
The defendants argued that the family waited too long to bring the case. The judge did not accept that argument at this stage, so the heirs' claims against Feigen's estate and its associated businesses can continue.
Not every defendant stays in the case. Clynes dismissed claims against Feigen's revocable trust, a legal arrangement that holds assets, and against its trustees. He found they had no link to money from the painting's sale. The heirs may bring those claims again if they find more evidence.
The judge has not yet ruled on who owns the painting or whether it was stolen. Those questions are still open, and the case will now go on to address them.
The dispute turns on provenance, which is the documented chain of who owned a work and when. Each step in that chain, from the 1972 purchase to the 2018 auction, is part of what the court must examine.


