Todd Boehly Says A24 Was Built on Saying No

Todd Boehly, whose holding company Eldridge has about $75 billion in assets, told a Doha audience that the early success of the film studio A24 came from knowing which films to walk away from. He spoke over the weekend in the closing fireside chat, titled "Playing to Win," at the Qatar Film Committee's Doha Industry Days, according to Deadline.
Boehly's account starts with a meeting of two finance people. He first connected with Daniel Katz, now an A24 co-founder, when Katz ran the film finance group at Guggenheim Partners in New York. Boehly was Guggenheim's president at the time, before he left to create Eldridge. Boehly said Katz had worked on Guggenheim's trading floor from about 2008 to 2012.
Boehly described Katz as someone who spotted risk early and was willing to refuse deals. He said Katz took few risks and said "no" a lot. In one example, Boehly said Katz warned him that Poseidon, a $160 million film directed by Wolfgang Petersen and backed by the Stark Investments slate, would be a disaster that cost too much and failed to earn its money back. The film struggled at the box office and did not take in enough to cover its print-and-advertising costs, the marketing and copies needed to get a film into cinemas.
Boehly also said he put $19 million of seed money into A24 when Katz launched the company in 2012 with David Fenkel and John Hodges. The studio was last publicly valued at $3.5 billion in June 2024, a figure that has not been updated in public since.
The studio's first big wins came from films bought cheaply and sold well. Boehly said Spring Breakers, the 2013 Harmony Korine film starring James Franco, Selena Gomez and Vanessa Hudgens, cost "a couple million dollars" to buy and made about $10 million quickly. The film went on to gross $31 million in total. Boehly called those early deals "structured finance trades," a term for arranging money so that risk is split up and sold on in pieces.
He also praised the studio's sense of timing. Boehly said A24 did an amazing job reading the cultural mood, pointing to Civil War and to Marty Supreme, which he said was timed to the rise of Timothée Chalamet.
What stands out here is how much of the talk was about saying no. A studio chief usually gets credit for the hits. Boehly chose to credit the films A24 passed on, and the cost of the ones it did not.
The conversation was held as part of Doha Industry Days, a gathering of filmmakers, financiers and distributors. Boehly's remarks did not announce any new deal or change to A24's ownership.


