Politics

Canada Poised to Choose Between German and South Korean Submarine Bids

Graham ThorntonPublished 4w ago4 min readBased on 2 sources
Reading level
Canada Poised to Choose Between German and South Korean Submarine Bids

Prime Minister Mark Carney is expected to announce the preferred bidder for Canada's 12-submarine procurement on Monday in Halifax, according to The Globe and Mail, citing two unnamed sources. The Prime Minister's Office declined to confirm the timing when asked on Sunday. The announcement will precede Carney's departure for the NATO leaders' summit in Turkey.

Two firms remain in contention. Germany's ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) has partnered with Norway to bid its 212CD diesel-electric model. South Korea's Hanwha is offering the KSS-III Batch-II, also a diesel-electric design. The Government of Canada qualified both suppliers in August 2025; in March 2026, the Defence Investment Agency sought input from Canadian industry on how the submarines would be maintained — a signal that support arrangements were being planned alongside the choice of vessel.

The financial stakes are substantial. The submarines themselves are projected at $20-billion to $30-billion; total lifecycle costs — operations, maintenance, and upgrades — could reach $40-billion to $50-billion. Canada has not purchased new submarines since the 1960s and currently operates four Victoria-class vessels acquired second-hand. An order of 12 boats has no precedent in the Royal Canadian Navy's history.

What Each Bidder Is Offering

Both competitors have attached industrial benefits packages to their proposals, understanding that Canadian jobs and investment will factor into the government's decision.

Hanwha pledges more than $70-billion in Canadian trade and investment and more than 25,000 jobs annually from 2026 to 2044. TKMS's offer was promoted partly by German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius, who stated in May that the German-Norwegian proposal would add $86-billion to Canada's GDP and create more than 650,000 job-years of employment across the country.

Both sets of numbers are projections provided by the bidders and should be treated with the caution that attaches to all industrial-benefits modelling. Ottawa will have conducted its own independent analysis; how closely the government's estimates align with either competitor's claims will likely become apparent in the weeks following the announcement.

Preferred Bidder, Not a Final Contract

Philippe Lagassé, a defence procurement scholar at Carleton University, told The Globe the announcement will probably designate a preferred bidder rather than execute a binding contract. Settling the final terms — price, industrial offsets, intellectual-property rights, support arrangements — could take years of negotiation.

This distinction has real operational significance. Canada's procurement of major weapons systems typically follows a pattern: government names a preferred supplier, then enters a prolonged phase of detailed negotiation before signatures. The F-35 fighter purchase and the National Shipbuilding Strategy's combat vessel contracts both went through extended post-selection talks. CPSP is almost certain to follow that same path, meaning Monday's announcement sets direction without locking in the final price or timeline.

The Broader Defence Context

The Carney government has pledged to raise defence spending to five per cent of GDP by 2035 — well above NATO's two-per-cent guideline and among the most ambitious targets in the alliance. The submarine programme is the single largest capital investment in that spending plan. Announcing the choice on the eve of a NATO summit is deliberate: Carney arrives in Turkey able to present a concrete capability commitment rather than a planning document.

The choice of Halifax as the announcement location carries its own weight. Irving Shipbuilding, which holds the surface-combatant contract under the National Shipbuilding Strategy, is based there; Atlantic Canada will be scrutinizing how submarine construction and maintenance work is distributed across regions. Neither TKMS nor Hanwha operates a Canadian shipyard; how either firm would establish domestic production capacity is one of the open questions that the preferred-bidder phase will begin to resolve.

The harder work — converting a government preference into a finished, costed, legally binding agreement — begins immediately after Monday.