Ryan McCartan To Star in Indie Crime Drama 'Only Good Feelings'

Ryan McCartan, best known to theatre audiences for playing Jay Gatsby on Broadway, will star in the indie crime drama Only Good Feelings. Variety reported the casting on 16 November 2026. The film is McCartan's debut in theatrical film, meaning movies shown in cinemas.
The story follows Benny, the character McCartan plays. Benny reconnects with a childhood friend, Kam, played by Elias Kacavas. Soon he is pulled into a plan involving robbery, insurance fraud and extortion, all aimed at getting the pair to Mexico.
Shervin Nassi directed the film and co-wrote the screenplay with Grant Schumacher. Michael Marlon is a producer. The cast also includes Heather Burns, Ajay Naidu, Amanda Steele and Ryan Whitney Newman. The whole film was shot in New York City.
McCartan's stage career started on Broadway in 2018, when he played Fiyero in Wicked. In 2020 he took over the role of Hans in Frozen. His most recent screen credit was the 2022 CW thriller series The Winchesters.
Distributor SNR Films plans a limited run in New York in February 2027. A limited run means the film opens in a small number of cinemas in one city first, before any wider release. No wider release dates have been announced.
Before that run, the film has been picking up awards on the festival circuit. According to Variety, it won best narrative film at the Manhattan Film Festival and best directorial debut at the Chicago Indie Film Awards. Its 2026 festival selections also include the San Francisco Jewish Film Festival, Dallas Movie Fest, the SoCal Film Awards and the San Diego Independent Cinema Awards.
For McCartan, the news is a move from the stage to the screen with a film built around a small group of characters and a single city. For audiences, the next date to note is February 2027, when the New York run is due to begin.


