Palace Bottom, United in the Bottom Three, and the Tightest Start in Years

Palace Bottom, United in the Bottom Three, and the Tightest Start in Years
Crystal Palace are bottom of the Premier League, England's top division, after 10 games, with seven points. They are not alone near the foot of the table. Manchester United are in the bottom three, and Sunderland are 19th on eight points, according to BBC Sport.
The bottom three are the teams in the most danger of relegation, which means being sent down to the second tier at the end of the season. Manchester United's position is a first. They have never been in the bottom three after 10 games of a Premier League season.
The gaps are small. Tottenham are 11th on 12 points, and Palace are on seven. That is only five points between the middle of the table and the bottom, the smallest gap at this stage for 24 years.
Palace have been here before at this point of a season, and it did not end in the drop. This is their third time bottom after 10 games. On both earlier occasions they finished 11th. Tony Pulis steered them there in 2013-14, after a poor start under Ian Holloway. Roy Hodgson did the same in 2017-18, following a rough beginning under Frank de Boer. Seven points is the fewest by a bottom side at this stage since 2002-03, when the bottom three all had eight.
Sunderland's eight points is the most for a side in 19th place after 10 games in 16 years. Wolves had nine in 2010-11 and survived by finishing 17th. Sunderland have kept their manager, Regis Le Bris, in charge. It is the first time Sunderland and Palace have been the bottom two after 10 games since 2013-14, when Sunderland survived under Gus Poyet.
History is not kind to clubs in this position. Of the 93 teams that have been in the bottom three after 10 games, 41 survived, a rate of 44%. In 19 of the 31 previous 20-team Premier League seasons, only one of the bottom three avoided relegation. Two or more stayed up in just 10 seasons, and none have done so in the past eight. The last time more than one of them survived was 2017-18, when all three did.
Only twice has every team in the bottom three after 10 games survived, and only twice has every one of them gone down. The best final finish by a team in that position is eighth. Bolton managed it in 2003-04, Tottenham in 2008-09 and Everton in 2017-18. The side in 18th place at this stage has been relegated in each of the past six seasons.
What does it mean? Early tables tell a story, but they rarely tell the ending. Plenty of teams have climbed out of a poor start, and plenty have not. For Palace, United and Sunderland, the next few weeks will decide whether these numbers become a warning or a footnote. The fans of all three clubs will be watching the table closely, and so will everyone else in the bottom half, because five points is not much of a gap at all.


