World

Inquest Hears Four Northern Rivers Babies Might Have Survived With Routine Checks

Elena MarquezPublished 6m ago3 min readBased on 1 source
Inquest Hears Four Northern Rivers Babies Might Have Survived With Routine Checks
Photo by Solen Feyissa on Unsplash

A coronial inquest in Lismore, New South Wales, has heard that four babies who died in the Northern Rivers region between 2022 and 2024 might have survived if they had received routine checks and follow-up care, according to The Guardian. A coronial inquest is a public hearing led by a coroner, an official who examines how and why a death occurred.

The four babies are identified as Baby DH, Baby D, Baby R and Baby B. Three were born in free births, which are planned without medical staff present, and one was born in a home birth. The inquest heard that the women chose free or home births for reasons including traumatic earlier experiences, a lack of trust in clinicians, and a lack of services.

Baby DH died about eight hours after birth. The birth was a free birth attended by a doula, a trained birth companion, with no medical professionals present. The inquest heard the baby turned purple, struggled to breathe and became floppy before death. The parents told the inquest they were worried, and that the doula reassured them the baby was fine before leaving. The doula denied many of the parents' claims and denied giving any clinical advice.

Neonatologist Associate Professor Nicholas Evans, a doctor who specialises in newborn care, told the inquest that Baby DH's complex heart abnormalities would have been readily detectable in a routine pregnancy scan. Such a scan would have led to a referral to a paediatric cardiologist, a heart specialist for children. Paediatric cardiologist Dr Paul Brooks told the inquest it was highly likely that all of the abnormalities would have been identified before birth. He said a routine scan would also have shown that Baby DH needed to be born at a major hospital with cardiac surgery capabilities.

Baby D's mother did not know she was carrying twins. She initially thought she had delivered the placenta before realising that she had given birth to a stillborn second twin. Experts at the inquest agreed it was impossible to know exactly why Baby D died. Evans said Baby D most likely died from respiratory distress caused by compromised heart function. He told the inquest the baby might have survived if someone capable of advanced resuscitation, the emergency treatment for a baby who has stopped breathing, had arrived in under 10 minutes.

Evans also told the inquest that the root cause of Baby D's death was that the twin pregnancy was not known before the births. He said a diagnosis at 18 weeks would usually have led to very close monitoring.

Baby R was born at 43 weeks and one day in a free birth and likely died of severe post-maturity, a condition in which a baby is born well past its due date. The inquest heard the standard practice is to induce birth or perform a caesarean section at 42 weeks, because an ageing placenta puts the baby at risk.